Violent America
1I was reading Mark Chu-Carroll’s why I won’t be at my high school reunion with considerable sadness and got to thinking about my own experience.
I went to school in ~10 different schools in 3 different continents. I only went to high school in the US for ~ 1 1/2 years, so my experience is limited. I was, however, a very socially inept 15 year old as a senior in high school, so I can claim some geek-in-high-school credit.
My first exposure to U.S. high school violence was in the second week of school. I was walking back from class when a typewriter shattered a window and flew across the walkway. Inside the classroom I saw several large boys attacking each other in a way I’d never seen before: they appeared to be trying to kill each other.
I’m no stranger to school fights. In Iran, even for a studious little boy like myself, fights are common place. I have no idea how many fights I had, but I’d guess maybe once a month. I probably saw at least one fight a day.
In England I had fewer fist fights. Maybe 4 or 5 in ~2 1/2 years.
I’ve seen far fewer fights in the U.S. The fights I have seen, however, have a sickening quality to them. The violent intent is incredible. Elsewhere the goal of the fight is to assert your superiority over the other person. Here it seems to be inflict terrible violence.
Back to Mark’s story: picturing a normal neighbourhood Iran, I can’t imagine a kid needlessly getting his fingers broken while others watched. I left when I was 12 so I may be mistaken, but I just can’t picture it. I don’t think it would fit the culture – someone would step in to stop it.
I can’t really see it happening in England either. I was there till I was 14 so I’m slightly better informed. I’m picturing my school. It just would not happen.
Let me clarify: in Iran I’ve seen grown men get into a fist fight over a taxi, and I’ve seen a crowd gather to egg them on.
I just can’t see the part, however, where one of the fighters, having clearly dominated the other, would start breaking fingers for fun while others watched. The watchers would stop watching – they’d step in.
…
My impression is that physical violence in school in the U.S. is less frequent but more serious than elsewhere. I can’t figure out why.
More than likely I’m mistaken. Let me know your impressions, particularly if you’ve gone to school in multiple countries / states.
Manage your expenses via Email, SMS, iPhone, Twitter, Voice (Call and say your expense), IM (Yahoo, AIM, MSN), or Web.