Tags vs Categories
Seems to me tags (ala technorati) are a significantly different thing from categories (what you see on the right hand side of this blog, as supported by wordpress, etc). Categories are a fairly static set of high level things that can be used to categorize your posts. Tags are a larger, more frequently changing set of keywords that are related to the specific content of your post. Thus, this post is in the Blogging category, but is tagged with
I’m trying TechnoTag by Keith McDuffee on this post; I tried Jerome’s Keyword Plugin on the last post with no luck. If this works, the abovementioned tags should be associated with this post. Let’s see.
UPDATE: Not happy. The solution offered by the various plugins seems to be link to technorati, as suggested by technorati. The problem is, my tags are belong to me. They’re not technorati’s tags, and I don’t want to link to them on every word just to tag a post. To be fair, I can link to any page as long as I follow the format they specify. But I don’t really want to link to any site. Links are quite disruptive.
Am I the only one that cares about this? I want to be able to assign keywords or tags to my posts without using categories and without having to alter the contents of my post in any way, including insertion of links. Maybe that’s unreasonable.
UPDATE #2: Quite happy. Jerome fixed me right up. I’ve got exactly what I was looking for via his plugin. Nicely done.
Manage your expenses via Email, SMS, iPhone, Twitter, Voice (Call and say your expense), IM (Yahoo, AIM, MSN), or Web.
Comments(7)
Technorati doesn’t seem to be indexing your site (it’s showing your last update at 62 days ago). Did you remove your link to Technorati that includes your site’s ID? Have you moved servers/URLs recently?
You don’t have to link your tags to Technorati at all. In fact, I specifically set the plugin’s default to *not* link directly to Technorati, but to create a local tag search. If you have any problems with my plugin, please let me know and I’d be happy to help you out.
jerome, much thanks for the reply. How do you check the indexing of my site on technoratoi to see the 62 days? I’ve claimed my blog, and according to my technorati profile I still have it. Haven’t moved servers/urls too recently (a month or three ago). My posts show up under the tags that correspond to my WP categories.
Much thanks for the offer of support on your plugin, I’ll take you up on it. To be specific, what I’m looking for is a way to tag my posts without linking to anything, even my own site.
(cross-posted to my site)
The tags normally show up only in your atom feed (add “atom” to the end of the URL you provided) since that’s where Technorati tries to pick them up. I can now see your tags listed in the feed, although they have yet to show up on Technorati. Did you enable the plugin before or after you made that post? Your categories are indeed showing up on Technorati, so it’s not the problem I mentioned earlier (enter your site’s URL to see what they’ve indexed).
As for not displaying tag links, if you don’t add the template tags for this plugin, then the only place the links will show up is your Atom feed. Mission accomplished.
jerome, much thanks, this was great. Excellent response. I’m a happy camper.
[...] I was looking for a solution for tagging my posts without having to use categories. I posted about it earlier. In a wonderful example of the power of blogging, jero [...]
[...] the difference between tags and categories until I read a post in the blog Standard Deviations, Tags vs Categories. This post had a good explanation of the subject, Seems to me tags (ala technorati) are a [...]
Tags and Categories in WordPress 2.3…
Since the upcoming WordPress 2.3 release will debut the new tagging system, I thought I’d take some time to address what it means to use “tags” versus using “categories”. These things mean different things to different people, as it’s really ju…